Water heater cost comparison
Compare your current water heater with a new one, electric, heat pump, natural gas or propane, using the uniform energy factor (UEF) on their ratings and the DOE test procedure's daily hot water for their usage bin.
Calculator
United States
Europe (EUR)
United Kingdom
Switzerland
Norway
Assumptions & limits
- Yearly energy = 365 × daily hot water × 8.24 lb/gal × 1.00 Btu/lb·°F × 67 °F ÷ UEF (DOE test procedure, 10 CFR 430 Appendix E). Daily hot water by usage bin: 10, 38, 55 or 84 gallons.
- Natural gas is costed per therm (100,000 Btu). Propane uses 91,452 Btu per gallon: an EIA “sample” conversion factor, which EIA recalculates each year (current annual values are in its Monthly Energy Review, Appendix A). It is editable.
- A gas or propane heater’s UEF counts the electricity it uses (the DOE test measures it separately). Here all of its energy is priced as its fuel, so where electricity costs more per unit of energy its true cost is somewhat higher; the result says so with the price ratio at your prices. How large that electric share is, is not calculated: no verified source yet.
- A heat pump water heater’s rating is measured with the room air at 67.5 °F; no adjustment is made for a colder or warmer space.
- Payback follows NIST Handbook 135. Water heating energy and the heater’s cost only.
Questions
- Where do I find the usage bin and UEF?
- On the EnergyGuide label or the AHRI certificate: the uniform energy factor (UEF) and the usage bin (very small, low, medium or high), which follows from the first-hour rating.
- Why use the test pattern instead of my own hot water use?
- The UEF is measured with that daily pattern, so it keeps the comparison consistent between models. Your own use scales both heaters’ costs alike.
- Can I compare gas with a heat pump water heater?
- Yes: choose each heater’s fuel. The gas heater is costed at your gas price and the heat pump at your electricity price.