EV vs gasoline in New York: an EV advantage below the middle of the US range
An EV costs $6.71 less per 100 miles to run in New York than a 24.8-mpg gas car, 27% below the US figure of $9.24. States more than 25% below it: 7 of 51.
Verdict: the EV is cheaper to run in New York, but the margin is thin. Electricity would only need to rise 70% (to 48.50¢/kWh), or gasoline fall to $2.40, for the 24.8-mpg gas car to win.
Key local inputs
- Regular gasoline (state)
- Source: EIA weekly retail gasoline & diesel prices, week of 2026-11-16. Version 2026-11-16+c381c5e9. Fetched 2026-11-20.
- Residential electricity (12-month average)
- Source: EIA-861M monthly sales and revenue by state: residential average price (Monthly-States sheet), 2025-09 to 2026-08. Version 2026-08+ea3ef7ff. Fetched 2026-11-20. Trailing 12 months: Σ revenue ÷ Σ sales (calculated by us from EIA-861M). Note: includes months EIA marks Preliminary.
- Reference gas car (new, non-hybrid, real-world)
- Source: EPA Automotive Trends Report 2025 (EPA-420-R-26-001), Table 4.1: real-world fuel economy by drive technology, MY2024, model year 2024. Version MY2024-final (2025 report)+d276eaba. Fetched 2026-10-02. Table 4.1, real-world, production-weighted (gasoline non-hybrid = ICE with and without stop/start).
- Reference EV (new, real-world)
- Source: EPA Automotive Trends Report 2025 (EPA-420-R-26-001), Table 4.1: real-world fuel economy by drive technology, MY2024, model year 2024. Version MY2024-final (2025 report)+d276eaba. Fetched 2026-10-02. Table 4.1, real-world, production-weighted (gasoline non-hybrid = ICE with and without stop/start).
What is different here
- GAP
An EV saves $6.71 per 100 miles here, $2.52 less than at US average prices (−27.3%). - RANK
New York ranks 45th of 51 for the EV's running-cost advantage. - THRESHOLD
The 24.8-mpg gas car would only cost less to run here if state gasoline fell below $2.40/gal (it is $4.063 now). - THRESHOLD
New York's electricity price could rise 70%, to 48.50¢/kWh, before the EV stopped being cheaper to run (today 28.60¢/kWh). - RANK
State and federal gasoline taxes here are $0.426/gal, the 39th highest of 51 (EIA, rates in effect July 1, 2026; local taxes not included).
More facts (3)
- DRIVER
Here the fuel price moves the answer most over its past-year range; nationally it is the fuel price. - VERDICT
The EV is cheaper to run here, unlike at national average prices. - TREND
The EV's running-cost advantage moved −4.1% since the previous data release.
Why New York is different
Why New York differs: the EV saves $2.52 per 100 miles less than at US average prices. Dearer electricity (28.60¢/kWh vs 18.04¢/kWh) accounts for $3.56; dearer gasoline ($4.063 vs $3.805 per gallon) offsets $1.04.
Of the two prices, the gasoline price moves this answer most here: over its recent range ($2.858 to $4.522) it shifts the EV advantage by $6.70 per 100 miles.
How close the verdict is
The EV keeps its lead here only while electricity stays below 48.50¢/kWh (recent range 26.46¢/kWh to 29.93¢/kWh) and gasoline stays above $2.40 (recent range $2.858 to $4.522).
Local EV facts
State and federal gasoline taxes: $0.426 a gallon, the 39th highest of 51 (EIA, rates in effect July 1, 2026; local taxes not included). That is 10% of the state price used above.
Public charging: 20,263 ports at 5,491 locations (AFDC, snapshot 2026-11-20). 16% of the ports are DC fast chargers, well below the US share of 30%.
Source: EIA Federal and state motor fuels taxes (Petroleum Marketing Monthly, fueltaxes.xlsx), rates in effect July 1, 2026, version July-2026-revised+2b969ff5, fetched 2026-10-02. Source: AFDC public charging station counts by state (U.S. DOE Alternative Fuels Data Center), snapshot 2026-11-20, version 2026-11-20+7406e03d, fetched 2026-11-20. Data: U.S. DOE Alternative Fuels Data Center; no endorsement implied.
State EV incentives and laws
The U.S. Department of Energy's Alternative Fuels Data Center lists 10 active state incentives and 18 laws or regulations for EVs in New York (last comprehensive review March 2026). Amounts and eligibility are on each AFDC page; none are included in the calculation.
- Alternative Fuel Vehicle Research and Development Funding
- Alternative Fueling Infrastructure Tax Credit
- Heavy-Duty Alternative Fuel and Advanced Vehicle Purchase Vouchers
- Electric Vehicle Emissions Inspection Exemption
- Electric Vehicle (EV) Rebate Program
- Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) Rebate and ZEV Fueling Infrastructure Grant for Municipalities
- Electric Vehicle (EV) Charger Rebate
- Vehicle Emissions Reduction and Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging Station Project Funding
- New York's National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure (NEVI) Planning
- Zero Emission School Bus and Infrastructure Funding
Source: AFDC state laws and incentives, state summary pages (U.S. DOE Alternative Fuels Data Center), as listed 2026-11-20, version 2026-11-20+cd7f114e, fetched 2026-11-20. Data: U.S. DOE Alternative Fuels Data Center; no endorsement implied.
Run the numbers for your situation
Where New York sits
- Connecticut: $6.49
- Michigan: $7.34
- New Hampshire: $6.65
- New York: $6.71
- Ohio: $7.46
- United States: $9.24
What moves the answer most here
- Gasoline price (past 52 weeks): swing $6.70 per 100 mi ($/gal 2.858 to 4.522)
- Electricity price (past 12 months): swing $1.17 per 100 mi ($/kWh 0.265 to 0.299)
Confidence range here
From the lowest and highest gasoline price of the past 52 weeks and electricity price of the past 12 months.
Show the work (local numbers)
Gas or petrol car: fuel cost per distance
- Fuel cost per distance:
c = $4.06/gal ÷ 24.833 mpg = $0.164/mi
EV: charging cost per distance
- Charging cost per distance:
c_d = $1,447.23/yr ÷ 15,000 mi/yr = $0.096/mi
Data notes
- EIA marks recent electricity months as preliminary.
- Reference vehicles are new model-year 2024 averages (EPA Automotive Trends, real-world); enter your own cars in the calculator.
- Energy cost only: maintenance, insurance and depreciation are not included.
Compare
- New Hampshire (in the table): $6.65
- Connecticut (in the table): $6.49
- Michigan: $7.34
- Ohio: $7.46
- Electricity cost in New York
Questions
- Is it cheaper to charge an EV than buy gas in New York?
- Yes at current prices: $9.65 of electricity vs $16.36 of gasoline per 100 miles (energy cost only, reference vehicles).
- At what gas price would a gas car be cheaper to run in New York?
- Below about $2.40/gal at today's 28.60¢/kWh electricity, for the reference vehicles. Change the vehicles in the calculator.
Sources & data version
- EIA weekly retail gasoline & diesel prices: week of 2026-11-16, version 2026-11-16+c381c5e9, fetched 2026-11-20.
- EIA-861M monthly sales and revenue by state: residential average price (Monthly-States sheet): 2025-09 to 2026-08, version 2026-08+ea3ef7ff, fetched 2026-11-20.
- EPA Automotive Trends Report 2025 (EPA-420-R-26-001), Table 4.1: real-world fuel economy by drive technology, MY2024: model year 2024, version MY2024-final (2025 report)+d276eaba, fetched 2026-10-02.
How this works: the numbers above come from public datasets and the same engine as the EV vs gas cost calculator, where the full method, every formula and its citation are explained.